Silicone spatula(for removing every last bit of sauce from the pot)
Instructions
Pour the whole jar of applesauce into your saucepan. Cook over medium heat until it just starts to bubble (CAREFUL, it splatters and it's hot), stirring once in a while to prevent burning.
Lower the heat, cover, and simmer, stirring every 10-20 minutes, for 3-5 hours or until the sauce cooks down to about ¼ of the original amount and is a rich brown color. As the sauce gets thicker, stir more frequently to prevent burning and check on it more often. You don't want to burn it!
Once the apple butter is the color and consistency you want, stir in brown sugar and spices. Remove from heat and carefully taste the apple butter by placing some on a spoon and allowing the spoon to cool completely. Adjust the flavor with more sugar, spices, or a little lemon juice, for tang.
Allow to cool completely, then transfer to a glass jar for storage.
Notes
I use unsweetened applesauce. If using with sweetened applesauce, start with ¼ cup sugar or less, then add more if needed.
If the apple butter is getting too thick but not brown enough to your liking, you can add a splash of water or apple juice or apple cider. But I have never needed to do that. You can sweeten the apple butter with maple syrup, honey, or any sweetener of your choice. Always add the sweetener at the very end to prevent burning.
Storage tips: Store refrigerated for up to 2 weeks. To prolong storage, ALWAYS use a clean utensil to get apple butter (do not re-insert the knife after getting some out), minimize keeping the jar open (close it as soon as you get the apple butter out), and place it back in the fridge immediately.
The nutrition facts are estimated per serving, assuming eight 1-ounce servings, but will vary depending on how much sugar and type of applesauce used.